Tax Study Released Today

A new study on the ramifications of lowering the state income tax was released today at a statehouse news conference. Bernie Koch, executive director of KEPC, and study author Dr. John Wong presented findings at the statehouse today. The study finds that, for every 1 job created, 1.63 are lost due to study released today finds that a lowering of the income tax would result in a loss of 1.63 jobs due to a reduction in overall state spending. The study was commissioned by the Kansas Economic Progress Council.

The press release is available here, and the ful text of the study is available here.

Dr. Wong’s slide deck is available here.

OPINION: Legislature should be careful about fixing the mess.

Tuesday’s general election, combined with the August primary, has resulted in big changes that mean a more moderate anti-Brownback Kansas Legislature next year.  This new majority of moderate Republicans and Democrats will be anxious to undo the state’s financial mess. But the 2017 Legislature should proceed with caution.

Part of the solution is to reverse the much-debated business income tax exemption.  There are two problems with that, other than the objections of Governor Brownback.

Even if lawmakers reverse the business exemption the first day of the session, it won’t bring any significant revenue to the state budget for another year.

The second problem is that the state’s revenue shortfalls were not solely caused by the business exemption.  About 70 percent of the revenue forgone since the income tax cuts came from the rate reductions granted to the remaining Kansans who pay individual income tax.

Then there are the problems with the Kansas tax structure that existed before the 2012 income tax cuts and continue today. Cited most often is the sales tax on food, but there are others.

For example, a 2011 study of business taxes in the region by Ernst and Young for the Arkansas Chamber of Commerce concluded Kansas has the highest effective tax rate in the region on business services, nearly 20 percent.  The excessive burden was the result of high sales and property taxes.

That disproportionate tax load has been intensified by the income tax cuts and the two state sales tax increases since 2012.

How should Kansas proceed?

An excellent model is the 1995 Governor’s Tax Equity Task Force authorized by executive order of Governor Bill Graves.  It was in response to strong anti-property tax sentiment following reappraisal and classification in the early 1990s.  Although now dated, it was, and still is, the most comprehensive overview ever done of the Kansas tax structure.

The 280 page all-inclusive study incorporated 14 research papers by respected Kansas authorities who were experts in specific fields of Kansas taxation.

The 21 member Task Force came up with a list of tax policy objectives that have stood the test of time, such as, “The state and local tax system should be balanced and diversified,” a warning since ignored.

The report said, “Because all revenue sources have their weaknesses, a balanced tax system will reduce the magnitude of problems caused by over reliance on a single tax source.”

We violated this standard by trying to eliminate the income tax and becoming overly reliant on a single revenue source, the sales tax.   With no action, that reliance will grow.

In 2012, Kansas hired celebrity economist Arthur Laffer for $75,000 to tell us to cut the income tax. In 2015, the legislature hired the consulting firm of Alvarez and Marsal for $2.6 million to do an efficiency study to tell us what we can do to try to live with the tax cuts.

As we look at tax policy solutions, we must take sufficient time and make thoughtful efforts to formulate the best answers toward finding our way out of our state’s fiscal disaster.

Something like the Tax Equity Task Force would be a good start to sorting out the solutions.

Bernie Koch of Wichita is the Executive Director of the Kansas Economic Progress Council.

 

 

 

 

KEPC UPDATE: Path forward, KDOT prep for cuts, Kansas opinions

In this issue … Finding a path forward after the election KDOT said to be preparing for cuts What Kansans think as the election nears   Finding a path forward after the election After the sweeping changes in the makeup of the Kansas Legislature brought by the primary election (with that trend expected to continue […]

[Continue reading…]

KEPC UPDATE: Kansans favor change to tax law; Transpo debate & info, Economic Lifelines lists candidates, 8th largest cut

In this issue … Majority of Kansans favor change to income tax law Transportation debate breaks out About transportation Economic Lifelines lists pro-transportation candidates National report says Kansas education had 8th largest cut   Majority of Kansans favor change to income tax law A scientific statewide poll of Kansans indicates 68 percent want to eliminate […]

[Continue reading…]

KEPC UPDATE: Revenue estimate questions, budget under water, Gov abandons useful analysis, college grads leaving

In this issue … Revenue estimate recommendations raise questions September revenues mean state budget is under water Kansas abandons a useful measure of success Regents say college grads leaving state   Revenue estimate recommendations raise questions This week, Governor Brownback’s Consensus Revenue Estimating Working Group issued its final recommendations.  In recent years, official revenue estimates […]

[Continue reading…]

KEPC UPDATE: Primary change, 2017, $15m lost in Osawatomie, credit rating, March of Folly

In this issue … Why the primary election means a change What can change in 2017? Osawatomie Post Audit: $15 million lost so far Credit rating drops The March of Folly   Why the primary election means a change By now you’ve heard about Tuesday’s primary election in Kansas and the discussion about how moderates […]

[Continue reading…]

KEPC UPDATE: Interim cmtes, transpo scorecard, budget, Goossen, FB experiment

In this issue … Interim Committees Approved Economic Lifelines produces scorecard on transportation votes Where we are on the budget Duane Goossen’s take on the budget Our Facebook Experiment   INTERIM COMMITTEES APPROVED The list of committees of the Kansas Legislature that will meet prior to the 2017 session will not include a study of […]

[Continue reading…]

KEPC UPDATE: Short breather then more problems…

A regular reader of the KEPC News told me this weekend (after the end of the Kansas Legislature’s special session on school finance) that he would like to read some good news here for a change. There is good news for the moment.  The legislature appears to have fixed the problem with state distribution of […]

[Continue reading…]

KEPC UPDATE: Lawmakers return, consequences for education, construction jobs disappear, higher ed tuition increases

In this issue … Lawmakers return for special session on Thursday Consequences for education are already here Construction jobs WAY down in Kansas Higher education tuition increases adopted   Lawmakers return for special session on Thursday Kansas legislators return to Topeka Thursday for a special session that will try to “fix” school finance and prevent […]

[Continue reading…]

KEPC UPDATE: Govt turmoil, revenues down, court waits, jobs tepid, higher ed tuition increases

In this issue … A week of turmoil for state government on several fronts Revenues down but Governor finds $25 million for a highway project Supreme Court now waiting for Brownback and the legislature Jobs report still tepid Higher education tuition increases proposed   A week of turmoil for state government on several fronts So […]

[Continue reading…]

KEPC UPDATE: Waiting for supreme court, budget, highway disaster, negative ratings, higher ed warnings…and we told you so…

In this issue … Waiting for the Supreme Court Brownback has until Thursday to decide budget The highway program disaster Negative bond ratings Higher education warnings on budget cuts Hate to say we told you so   Waiting for the Supreme Court As if Kansas public schools didn’t have enough to worry about these days […]

[Continue reading…]